A 31-year-old man with a history of arrests has been charged in connection with a fatal hit-and-run in the Bronx that resulted in the death of a cancer survivor. The individual was already in custody for a separate violent assault when the new charges were filed. This case has drawn attention to ongoing discussions regarding criminal justice policies and public safety.
Story Highlights
- Timothy Bohler, 31, faces charges in a deadly Bronx hit-and-run that killed Lelawattie Narine.
- Bohler was previously arrested over 20 times for various offenses and was incarcerated for a machete attack when charged for the fatal incident.
- The case has prompted renewed scrutiny of criminal justice policies and their impact on repeat offenders.
- Victims’ families and community members have called for stricter enforcement and accountability.
Details of the Case
Timothy Bohler has been identified as the individual charged in the hit-and-run that claimed the life of Lelawattie Narine in the Bronx. Records indicate Bohler has a history of arrests, including for violent offenses such as assaults, robbery, and weapons possession. At the time of the new charges, he was already incarcerated following a machete attack in January 2024, which reportedly resulted in severe injuries to another individual.
The incident involving Ms. Narine has brought to the forefront concerns about the effectiveness of current criminal justice policies in managing repeat offenders and ensuring public safety.
Community Response and Calls for Action
The family of Lelawattie Narine, including her son Darshan, has expressed both relief at the charges filed against Bohler and frustration with the system. Similarly, the family of Rakeem Young, who sustained injuries in the machete attack, has advocated for more stringent measures to address violent crime.
This case has fueled public discourse in New York regarding law and order, with residents and various stakeholders calling upon district attorneys, judges, and lawmakers to prioritize public safety. There is increasing pressure on law enforcement to address perceived gaps in the system that may contribute to patterns of re-offense. The ongoing discussion emphasizes the importance of accountability for repeat violent offenders.
Watch the report: Career Criminal with 45 Priors Charged in Fatal Hit-and-Run While Jailed for Machete Attack – YouTube
Sources:
https://nypost.com/2025/10/12/us-news/nyc-machete-attack-suspect-charged-in-fatal-hit-and-run